What Jones reported

Jones published a preliminary report in Iron Man magazine. Casey Viator trained from 1 to 29 May 1973 at Colorado State University, using Nautilus machines only. The workouts were brief single sets to failure with heavy use of negative reps. Later accounts list 12 sessions of under 30 minutes each, all supervised by Jones. The figures for Viator were:

The headline number most people repeat, 63 pounds of muscle, is Jones's estimate. Viator's scale weight went up by about 45 pounds.

The second subject was Jones himself, then in his forties, who trained for 22 days and reported about 15 pounds of muscle gained.

Casey Viator's starting point

Viator was no ordinary trainee. He won the 1971 Mr. America at 19, after ten months training under Jones, and by late 1972 he weighed about 200 pounds. In early January 1973 he lost most of a finger in a work accident and nearly died from an allergic reaction to an anti-tetanus injection. He then did no training for about four months. By Jones's account he lost 33.63 pounds over that period, 18.75 of it attributed to the accident and the reaction.

So the experiment began with a champion bodybuilder who was well below his usual weight. Regaining muscle you recently carried is far quicker than building new muscle, and Jones's own report concedes that neither subject was average and that both were rebuilding earlier size.

The caveats

  • Two subjects, and no control group.
  • The main subject was regaining weight lost after the accident and the layoff.
  • The muscle figure is a calculation from an estimated fat loss.
  • Jones designed the study, trained the subject, reported the results and sold the equipment used.
  • Mike Mentzer, a Jones admirer, wrote in Heavy Duty II that observers described Jones force-feeding Viator, and said he was sceptical of Jones's claim that fat had been converted into muscle.

What it does and does not show

The experiment shows that a very gifted lifter, regaining recently lost size, can put on weight fast with brief, hard, infrequent workouts. It cannot show that HIT builds muscle faster than other training for an ordinary lifter, because nothing was compared and the subject was exceptional.

For the case for and against low-volume training, see one set vs multiple sets. For how Jones and his ideas shaped HIT, see Arthur Jones and Nautilus and Mike Mentzer's training method. The evidence that matters most for you is in your own records: evidence of adaptation explains what to look for.