The short answer
If your only goal is the most muscle possible and you have time to recover from it, the research favours more than one set per muscle per week. If you want most of the strength benefit for very little time, one hard set per exercise does well. Mike Mentzer's argument for one set adds a third factor, recovery, and that part is harder to test.
What the meta-analyses found
Strength
James Krieger's 2009 meta-regression pooled 14 studies and found that 2 to 3 sets per exercise produced about 46 percent greater strength gains than one set, in trained and untrained people alike. Going to 4 to 6 sets added nothing significant over 2 to 3. Ralston and colleagues' 2017 meta-analysis of weekly set volume reached the same direction: higher weekly volume gave more strength, and low volume still produced substantial gains.
A large meta-regression by Pelland and colleagues in Sports Medicine, covering 67 studies, found strength rising with volume, with diminishing returns much more pronounced than for muscle growth. For strength, the first sets do most of the work.
Muscle size
Krieger's 2010 meta-analysis of hypertrophy found multiple sets associated with about 40 percent greater effect sizes than a single set. Schoenfeld, Ogborn and Krieger's 2017 dose-response analysis put a number on each extra weekly set: about 0.37 percent more muscle gain per set. The Pelland analysis also found muscle growth rising with volume, flattening more slowly than strength.
One controlled trial
In Schoenfeld's 2019 trial, 34 trained men did one, three or five sets per exercise, three times a week, for eight weeks. Strength and endurance gains were similar across groups. Muscle growth favoured the higher-volume groups at several sites. The authors noted that the one-set group got its strength gains from three sessions of about 13 minutes a week.
| Study | Outcome | Finding |
|---|---|---|
| Krieger 2009, meta-regression | Strength | 2 to 3 sets per exercise beat 1 set by about 46 percent; 4 to 6 sets no better than 2 to 3 |
| Krieger 2010, meta-analysis | Muscle size | Multiple sets gave about 40 percent larger effect sizes than 1 set |
| Schoenfeld, Ogborn & Krieger 2017 | Muscle size | Graded dose-response: more weekly sets, more growth |
| Ralston et al. 2017 | Strength | Higher weekly set volume gave more strength; low volume still gave large gains |
| Schoenfeld et al. 2019, trial | Both | 1, 3 and 5 sets gave similar strength; more sets gave more growth |
| Pelland et al., meta-regression | Both | Both rise with volume; returns diminish faster for strength |
What the studies leave open
Training studies run for weeks or months. Carpinelli and Otto's review covered trials of 4 to 25 weeks, and Schoenfeld's 2019 trial lasted eight. That says little about what happens over years. Studies also count sets differently. Pelland and colleagues found that how you count sets for muscles that only assist in an exercise, such as the triceps in a bench press, changes the result, and settled on counting those as half a set. By that count, one set each of a pulldown, a row and a chin-up is three sets for the back and one and a half for the biceps.
Effort varies too. Some studies take sets to failure and others stop short, so a single set in one study may not match the all-out set HIT asks for.
The case for one set
Single-set training has its own researchers. Ralph Carpinelli and Robert Otto's 1998 review in Sports Medicine found that most single-versus-multiple-set studies of the time showed no significant difference in strength or hypertrophy over 4 to 25 weeks, and argued for time-efficient, low-volume training. A group including James Steele, James Fisher and Paulo Gentil responded to the Schoenfeld analysis with a letter questioning how reliable meta-analyses are for evaluating training programmes.
The practical argument is time. If one set per exercise gives you most of the strength gain and a good part of the growth, the extra sets buy a smaller return for every hour spent. Many lifters will happily make that trade.
Mentzer's argument is about recovery
Mentzer did not claim a second set adds zero stimulus. In his 1998 seminar he argued that whatever little extra growth a second set might trigger is outweighed by the cost: it doubles the inroad into a limited recovery ability. In his system, volume, frequency and intensity trade off against each other, and he cut volume so he could keep every set at failure and still recover between workouts spaced four to seven days apart.
The meta-analyses above do not isolate that combination of one set to failure with several days between workouts. Treat his position as a coherent argument the studies have not settled either way. He was not rigid about it in practice either: in one interview he told sceptics to start with one set and try two if one did not work.
What to do with this
Start with one working set per exercise taken to failure, as described in one set to failure, and track whether you get stronger session to session. If you stall, Mentzer's first fix was more rest, covered in stalls and plateaus and the rest-day calculator. If you care most about size and recover well, adding a second set on some exercises is what the volume research would suggest. Use the Mentzer calculator to decide when you have earned more weight.
For the wider method, read what High-Intensity Training is and Mike Mentzer's training method.