How the selector decides
The answers are checked in order, and the first rule that fits wins. Pain or an injury that limits a lift sends you to the break-in with no failure sets until a professional clears you. Being new or back from a long layoff, or not being sure your technique repeats, also means a break-in first. A stall only points to the Consolidated routine when it is clean: three cycles, full rest, no intensity techniques, and most lifts flat. Everything else starts on the Ideal routine.
| Your answers | Result |
|---|---|
| Two years of lifting, solid technique, no pain, still improving | Ideal routine |
| Experienced with one set to failure, stalled, three clean cycles with most lifts flat | Consolidated routine |
| Same lifter, but the stall came on short rest or with forced reps | Ideal routine, with more rest days |
| Back after a year off, technique not sure | Break in first, then Ideal |
| Any experience, a shoulder that hurts on presses | Break in first, after a professional has looked at it |
The Ideal routine
The Ideal routine is the four-workout rotation Mentzer set out in Heavy Duty II: Mind and Body (pp.47-48). You train chest and back, then legs, then delts and arms, then legs again, and start over. One workout comes about every 96 hours. As you get stronger, the gaps get longer.
Each exercise gets one working set to failure after warm-ups, in a strict 6-10 reps. Three lifts get their own ranges: 1-3 on the incline press, 3-5 on dips, 12-20 on calf raises. Inclines and dips come straight after an isolation movement with no rest, the pre-exhaust pairing, so the compound lift starts with the target muscle already tired. Between exercises you rest until your breathing settles.
| Exercise | Reps | Rest after |
|---|---|---|
| Pec deck or dumbbell flyes | 6-10 | None. Straight to incline press |
| Incline press | 1-3 | Until your breathing settles |
| Pullover | 6-10 | None. Straight to palms-up pulldown |
| Palms-up pulldown | 6-10 | Until your breathing settles |
| Deadlift | 6-10 | Workout done |
| Exercise | Reps | Rest after |
|---|---|---|
| Leg extension | 6-10 | None. Straight to leg press |
| Leg press | 6-10 | Until your breathing settles |
| Standing calf raise | 12-20 | Workout done |
| Exercise | Reps | Rest after |
|---|---|---|
| Lateral raise | 6-10 | Until your breathing settles |
| Rear-delt raise | 6-10 | Until your breathing settles |
| Barbell curl | 6-10 | Until your breathing settles |
| Triceps pressdown | 6-10 | None. Straight to dips |
| Dips | 3-5 | Workout done |
| Exercise | Reps | Rest after |
|---|---|---|
| Leg extension | 6-10 | None. Straight to squat |
| Squat | 6-10 | Until your breathing settles |
| Calf raise | 12-20 | Workout done |
The Consolidated routine
The Consolidated routine keeps only compound lifts: squat or leg press, palms-up pulldown, dips, deadlift or shrugs, and press behind the neck. You do a few of them per workout, about once a week, and less often as you get stronger. The isolation work goes because every set draws on the same recovery. As you get stronger you lift heavier weights, and each workout costs more to recover from.
In Heavy Duty II he wrote that everyone ends up training once a week or less, on two or three mostly compound sets. The palms-up pulldown covers the biceps, and dips cover the triceps and chest. His writings list the lifts without fixing one split, so here is one way to split them into two alternating workouts:
| Exercise | Reps | Rest after |
|---|---|---|
| Squat or leg press | 6-10 | Until your breathing settles |
| Palms-up pulldown | 6-10 | Until your breathing settles |
| Dips | 6-10 | Workout done |
| Exercise | Reps | Rest after |
|---|---|---|
| Deadlift or shrugs | 6-10 | Until your breathing settles |
| Press behind the neck | 6-10 | Until your breathing settles |
| Standing calf raise (optional) | 12-20 | Workout done |
Ideal vs Consolidated: when to switch
Mentzer expected strength to go up from one workout to the next. A single flat workout means add a rest day. The switch comes when about three full cycles of the Ideal routine pass without real strength gains on most lifts, with full rest taken and no forced reps or negatives muddying the picture.
Take a break before you switch. His stall advice in Heavy Duty II (p.63) was two weeks off, then the compound-only routine. At one workout every four days, three cycles is about seven weeks, so do not judge the Ideal routine on a fortnight. The rest day calculator handles the day-to-day call, and the double progression calculator tells you when a lift has earned more weight.
Before either: the break-in
Neither routine is a first week in the gym. In High-Intensity Training the Mike Mentzer Way (ch.9 and ch.11) new lifters spend the early months learning form, and going to absolute failure is described as unnecessary and even risky for someone coming off the couch. The break-in lasts one to two weeks below failure, longer if you are still sore.
The same applies if you are returning after a long layoff or cannot yet repeat your technique rep for rep. If something hurts, get it looked at first and leave failure sets out until it is cleared. The Failure Point app will log one working set per exercise and work out the next target, so the three-cycle check will be a matter of reading the numbers.